Migration guide

Swap the forms first. Then cancel.

Contacts and the Master Unsubscribe List export from Benchmark as CSV or Excel. Bounces export one campaign at a time. When you cancel, the signup forms stop saving contacts, so the order matters.

On Benchmark Email$89/mo
On Bluey$30/mo

10,000 contacts, 40,000 emails/month · Typical migration: 1–2 days of work, over about a week

In short

Moving from Benchmark Email to Bluey is one to two days of work for most accounts. Export each list from Contacts › More Options › Export to File, and the Master Unsubscribe List from its own ⋯ menu. Bounced addresses export from Reports, one campaign at a time. Automations stop working when you cancel and are rebuilt in Bluey. Replace every Benchmark signup form before you cancel, because Benchmark stops saving new signups from the cancellation date and deletes the account data 30 days later. At 10,000 contacts, Benchmark Pro is $89 a month on monthly billing; 40,000 emails a month on Bluey Grow is $30.

What transfers, and what you rebuild

Stated up front, because finding out mid-migration is how a two-day job becomes a two-week one.

WhatStatusDetail
ContactsTransfersContacts › list › More Options › Export to File, CSV or Excel. Choose Select All for fields.
UnsubscribesTransfersContacts › Master Unsubscribe List › ⋯ › Export to file. Import it into Bluey first.
BouncesPartialReports › campaign › Activity Details › Bounces › Export. One campaign at a time, so start with your recent ones.
TemplatesRebuildBenchmark documents no template export. Rebuild the few you reuse in Bluey’s editor.
AutomationsRebuildNo export, and they stop working on cancellation. Bluey templates welcome, cart and win-back flows.
Forms and landing pagesRebuildBenchmark forms stop saving signups when you cancel. Replace them before you do.

The migration plan, in order

  1. 1Day 1 — before any send
    Authenticate your sending domainPublish SPF, DKIM and, if you use one, DMARC records for the domain you will send from. Gmail and Yahoo have required authentication and one-click unsubscribe from bulk senders since February 2024, and an unauthenticated first send from a new platform is the fastest route to the spam folder. This is a DNS change and takes about fifteen minutes; allow up to a few hours for propagation.
  2. 2Day 1
    Export contacts, unsubscribes and bouncesExport every list with all fields, then the Master Unsubscribe List. Bounces come out per campaign from Reports, so export the last few months of campaigns to catch most of them.
  3. 3Day 1
    Import suppressions before contactsImport unsubscribes and bounces into Bluey first, so nobody who opted out is ever mailable, even briefly.
  4. 4Day 2
    Replace signup forms and landing pagesBuild each form in Bluey and swap the embed on your site. Do this before anything else changes: Benchmark stops saving signups from the day you cancel, and those people are lost.
  5. 5Week 1–2
    Run Bluey and Benchmark in parallelSplit the audience rather than duplicating it: send to one segment from Bluey and leave the rest on Benchmark. You get a like-for-like comparison of delivery, engagement and cost on your own data, and nobody receives the same campaign twice. Do not run both against the same contacts — that is the one way to make a careful migration look sloppy to your readers.
  6. 6Week 2 — gradually
    Ramp volume rather than switching itStart with your most engaged segment — people who opened or clicked in the last 30 days — and increase volume over several days. Receiving servers judge a new sending pattern partly on engagement, so leading with your best contacts builds reputation, while leading with your whole list including two-year-dormant addresses damages it. If you were on a dedicated IP, treat the new one as cold and warm it deliberately.
  7. 7Week 3
    Cancel once nothing points at BenchmarkCheck that no page still uses a Benchmark form or landing page, then cancel. Benchmark keeps account data for up to 30 days after the cancellation date, then permanently deletes it.

Mistakes people make leaving Benchmark Email

Each of these is recoverable, and each is much cheaper to avoid than to fix.

Cancelling while the old forms are still liveBenchmark says contacts who sign up after the cancellation date are not saved, and landing pages go inactive. Any form you forgot to replace silently loses every new signup.
Leaving the suppression list behindExporting subscribers without also exporting unsubscribes, bounces and complaints is the single most common migration error. The result is that people who opted out of Benchmark receive your first Bluey campaign — which is a compliance breach in most markets and a fast way to breach Gmail's 0.3% complaint threshold on your very first send. Export suppressions and import them before anything else.
Exporting bounces from one campaign onlyBounces export per campaign, not as one list. If you export only the last send, older hard bounces come back on your first Bluey campaign. Older help articles describe “Benchmark Classic”, so menu names may differ slightly in the current app.
Importing the whole list, including the dead partA migration is the best opportunity you will get to drop contacts who have not engaged in a year or more. Bringing them across because storage is free is a mistake: they do not open, some addresses have gone stale and now hard-bounce, and a few have become spam traps. They will not cost you money on send-based billing, but they will cost you deliverability on the send that matters most — your first.

Migration FAQ

How do I export contacts from Benchmark Email?

Open Contacts, choose the list, then More Options › Export to File. Pick All Emails, choose Select All for fields, and download as CSV or Excel. The Master Unsubscribe List exports separately.

Can I downgrade to Benchmark’s free plan instead of cancelling?

Benchmark’s help centre says paid accounts cannot downgrade to the free plan, although its pricing page describes downgrading as easy. Check with Benchmark before relying on it, and export everything either way.

What happens to my data when I cancel Benchmark?

Automations stop, signup forms stop saving contacts and landing pages go inactive. Data is kept for up to 30 days after the cancellation date, then permanently deleted.

How much will I save?

At 10,000 contacts, Benchmark Pro is $89 a month on monthly billing (checked 19 November 2026). Sending 40,000 emails a month on Bluey Grow is $30, with unlimited contacts.

Free · 7 days

Run both in parallel. Then decide.

Seven days of full access, no credit card. Import a segment, send from Bluey while Benchmark Email handles the rest, and compare delivery and cost on your own data before you move the domain.