Bring the subscribers. Leave the add-on bill.
Buttondown exports every subscriber in one CSV, with their type and tags, and every email as Markdown. Paid subscriptions are the one part that needs thought before you move.
Typical migration: About a day of work
Moving a free newsletter from Buttondown to Bluey takes a day. Export subscribers from the Subscribers tab (click Export with nothing selected to get everyone); the CSV includes subscriber_type, tags and subscription dates. Import Regular subscribers as mailable and Unsubscribed, Undeliverable and Complained as suppressions. Your archive exports from the Emails tab as Markdown files. If you run paid subscriptions, they live in your own Stripe account, and deleting a subscriber in Buttondown does not cancel their Stripe subscription — so decide how paid readers will be handled before you switch, because Bluey does not run paid newsletters.
What transfers, and what you rebuild
Stated up front, because finding out mid-migration is how a two-day job becomes a two-week one.
| What | Status | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Subscribers | Transfers | Subscribers › Export with nothing selected exports everyone as CSV. |
| Tags and metadata | Transfers | Tags come out semicolon-separated; split them into Bluey tags on import. |
| Unsubscribed, Undeliverable, Complained | Transfers | Identified by subscriber_type. Import them into Bluey as suppressions, first. |
| Email archive | Partial | Emails › Export gives a CSV plus one Markdown file per email. Republish on your own site if you want the archive public. |
| Paid subscriptions | Rebuild | Billing stays in your Stripe account. Bluey does not run paid newsletters. |
| Automations | Rebuild | No export is documented. Rebuild your welcome email in Bluey. |
| Embed form | Rebuild | Replace the form that posts to buttondown.com with a Bluey form embed. |
The migration plan, in order
- 1Day 1 — before any sendAuthenticate your sending domainPublish SPF, DKIM and, if you use one, DMARC records for the domain you will send from. Gmail and Yahoo have required authentication and one-click unsubscribe from bulk senders since February 2024, and an unauthenticated first send from a new platform is the fastest route to the spam folder. This is a DNS change and takes about fifteen minutes; allow up to a few hours for propagation.
- 2Day 1Export subscribers and the archiveExport subscribers with nothing selected, then export your emails from the Emails tab. Keep the Markdown files somewhere safe: deleting the account removes everything, and a snoozed newsletter does not keep its archive online.
- 3Day 1Sort by subscriber_typeUnsubscribed, Undeliverable and Complained go into Bluey as suppressions first. Regular subscribers are your mailable list. Unactivated subscribers never confirmed, so leave them out.
- 4Day 1Swap the signup formReplace Buttondown’s embed, which posts to buttondown.com, with a Bluey form on your site and any link-in-bio page.
- 5Week 1–2Run Bluey and Buttondown in parallelSplit the audience rather than duplicating it: send to one segment from Bluey and leave the rest on Buttondown. You get a like-for-like comparison of delivery, engagement and cost on your own data, and nobody receives the same campaign twice. Do not run both against the same contacts — that is the one way to make a careful migration look sloppy to your readers.
- 6Week 2 — graduallyRamp volume rather than switching itStart with your most engaged segment — people who opened or clicked in the last 30 days — and increase volume over several days. Receiving servers judge a new sending pattern partly on engagement, so leading with your best contacts builds reputation, while leading with your whole list including two-year-dormant addresses damages it. If you were on a dedicated IP, treat the new one as cold and warm it deliberately.
Mistakes people make leaving Buttondown
Each of these is recoverable, and each is much cheaper to avoid than to fix.
Migration FAQ
Can I move my paid newsletter to Bluey?
Bluey does not run paid subscriptions, so it suits free newsletters best. If you charge, billing stays in your Stripe account; decide how paying readers are handled before you switch.
Does my Buttondown archive come with me?
Emails export as Markdown files plus a CSV of subjects and dates. Republish them on your own site if you want a public archive.
Which subscribers should I import?
Regular subscribers as mailable. Unsubscribed, Undeliverable and Complained as suppressions. Leave Unactivated out.
Is Bluey cheaper than Buttondown?
Buttondown is free for the first 100 subscribers, then priced on a slider plus add-ons — $9 for paid subscriptions and tagging, $29 for automations. Bluey bills by emails sent, with automation included: Spark from $7 a month for 6,000 emails.
Run both in parallel. Then decide.
Seven days of full access, no credit card. Import a segment, send from Bluey while Buttondown handles the rest, and compare delivery and cost on your own data before you move the domain.