Keep the designs you built. Pay for what you send.
Subscribers and the suppression list export cleanly from Campaign Monitor, with the reason for every suppression. Custom HTML templates export too. Templates made in the drag-and-drop builder do not.
10,000 contacts, 40,000 emails/month · Typical migration: 1–3 days of work, over one to two weeks
Moving from Campaign Monitor to Bluey takes most accounts one to three days. Export each list from Lists & subscribers › ⋯ › Export list, choosing All Subscribers and your custom fields. Export the suppression list from Lists & subscribers › Suppressions; each row says whether it was unsubscribed, marked as spam or bounced. Custom HTML templates export from the template menu, but builder templates cannot be exported, so rebuild those. Journeys are rebuilt too. At 5,001–10,000 contacts, Campaign Monitor Lite is $117 a month for 50,000 sends; 40,000 emails a month on Bluey Grow is $30.
What transfers, and what you rebuild
Stated up front, because finding out mid-migration is how a two-day job becomes a two-week one.
| What | Status | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Subscribers | Transfers | Lists & subscribers › list › ⋯ › Export list, CSV or tab-delimited. Choose All Subscribers and tick your custom fields. |
| Suppression list | Transfers | Lists & subscribers › Suppressions › Export list. Each row carries a reason. Import it into Bluey first. |
| Custom HTML templates | Transfers | Template menu › Export. Only templates that were custom HTML to begin with. |
| Builder templates | Rebuild | Campaign Monitor says builder templates cannot be exported. Rebuild them in Bluey’s editor. |
| Geolocation data | Rebuild | Campaign Monitor says it cannot be exported. |
| Journeys | Rebuild | No export is documented. Bluey templates welcome, cart and win-back flows. |
| Forms | Rebuild | Rebuild in Bluey’s form builder and swap the embed on your site. |
The migration plan, in order
- 1Day 1 — before any sendAuthenticate your sending domainPublish SPF, DKIM and, if you use one, DMARC records for the domain you will send from. Gmail and Yahoo have required authentication and one-click unsubscribe from bulk senders since February 2024, and an unauthenticated first send from a new platform is the fastest route to the spam folder. This is a DNS change and takes about fifteen minutes; allow up to a few hours for propagation.
- 2Day 1Export every list, then the suppressionsEach list exports as its own file, so work through all of them, choosing All Subscribers and your custom fields. Then export the suppression list, which keeps the reason for each address.
- 3Day 1Import suppressions before subscribersImport the suppression list into Bluey first, so nobody who unsubscribed, complained or bounced is ever mailable, even briefly. Then merge and import the list files.
- 4Day 2Export HTML templates, rebuild the restExport any custom HTML templates and import them into Bluey. Rebuild builder templates and the journeys carrying real traffic, then send yourself tests on a phone and a desktop.
- 5Week 1–2Run Bluey and Campaign Monitor in parallelSplit the audience rather than duplicating it: send to one segment from Bluey and leave the rest on Campaign Monitor. You get a like-for-like comparison of delivery, engagement and cost on your own data, and nobody receives the same campaign twice. Do not run both against the same contacts — that is the one way to make a careful migration look sloppy to your readers.
- 6Week 2 — graduallyRamp volume rather than switching itStart with your most engaged segment — people who opened or clicked in the last 30 days — and increase volume over several days. Receiving servers judge a new sending pattern partly on engagement, so leading with your best contacts builds reputation, while leading with your whole list including two-year-dormant addresses damages it. If you were on a dedicated IP, treat the new one as cold and warm it deliberately.
- 7Week 3–4Keep the old account open for late repliesCampaign Monitor’s own migration guide says to keep the old account for one to two weeks to catch late unsubscribes and bounces. Switching to pay-per-campaign billing keeps it open without a monthly plan. Its terms let it delete your content within 30 days of closing.
Mistakes people make leaving Campaign Monitor
Each of these is recoverable, and each is much cheaper to avoid than to fix.
Migration FAQ
How do I export subscribers from Campaign Monitor?
Go to Lists & subscribers, choose the list, then ⋯ › Export list. Pick All Subscribers, CSV, and the fields you want, including custom fields. Each list exports as a separate file.
Can I export Campaign Monitor templates?
Only custom HTML templates, from the template menu. Campaign Monitor says templates made in its email builder cannot be exported, so rebuild those in Bluey.
What happens when I close my Campaign Monitor account?
Scheduled campaigns are cancelled and every user loses access, though links and images in sent campaigns keep working. Its terms let Campaign Monitor delete your content within 30 days.
How much will I save?
At 5,001–10,000 contacts on monthly billing, Campaign Monitor Lite is $117 a month for 50,000 sends, and Essentials is $182 (checked 19 November 2026). Sending 40,000 emails a month on Bluey Grow is $30.
Run both in parallel. Then decide.
Seven days of full access, no credit card. Import a segment, send from Bluey while Campaign Monitor handles the rest, and compare delivery and cost on your own data before you move the domain.